Talk:Thomas Henry Huxley

Latest comment: 5 years ago by Kalki in topic Unsourced

This is the talk page for discussing improvements to the Thomas Henry Huxley page.


2008 comments edit

The first and last quote in the Unsourced section are surely the same thing. Can we just remove the first or should they both be kept (but linked in some way)? --nawab 15:16, 17 July 2008 (UTC)Reply

Done. The issue is dealt with in more detail in the WP article, and refs given for access to the dozen or so reports which survived. These two quotes are reasonably typical. --Macdonald-Ross 07:03, 19 July 2008 (UTC)Reply

"extremely stupid" edit

I added a second version of the "extremely stupid" quote, since one of the sources mentioned for it (at http://aleph0.clarku.edu/huxley/Book/Recep.html) had a version not containing the "...of me..." phrase. However most of the online versions of even this text report it as not containing the latter phrase, which I am beginning to suspect is a modern interpolation. Further research on this is warranted for anyone who wishes to pursue it (I shall not, I think).17:01, 23 February 2017 (UTC)

Unsourced edit

These require citations to adequate sources before being placed into the main article.

On Bishop Wilberforce's Death edit

"Wilberforce's brains have at last come into contact with reality, and the result was fatal."

I have heard or read this quote on occasion, and it should be addressed here. I am not familiar enough with the guidelines to know if this is a quote, a misquote, or should classified as 'Attributed'. This is also from a secondary source, and I took the liberty of changing the tenses to make it a quote. But since the attestation is insecure, I don't see how a small relevant change matters. I can't get access to the primary source, so I don't know how to handle that, either.

Secondary source: Chemers, Michael. Staging stigma: a critical examination of the American freak show. Springer, 2016, p145. "Samuel [Wilberforce] was killed in 1873 by a fall from a horse: Huxley is said to have quipped, rather coldly, that Wilberforce's brains had at last come into contact with reality and the result had been fatal."

Primary source, cited in secondary: A.R. Ashwell and Reginald Carton Wilberforce, Life of Samuel Wilberforce, with Selections from his Diary and Correspondence [1879-1882] vols. I-III).

Return to "Thomas Henry Huxley" page.